1. Introduction

The rapid development of industry and the extensive use of fossil fuels have led to a sharp increase in greenhouse gas concentrations since the last century. CO₂, the major component of greenhouse gases, accounts for approximately 72% of total emissions^[1]. China’s carbon emissions have increased significantly since 2013 and are expected to reach their peak by 2030^[2]. As key technologies for CO₂ emission reduction, carbon capture, utilization, and storage have attracted considerable attention in recent decades. In particular, CO₂ utilization, which involves converting CO₂ into high-value fuels or chemicals, has been widely studied because it contributes to achieving a sustainable carbon cycle.

The conversion or catalytic transformation of CO₂ into chemicals is a promising approach to utilize excess CO₂. However, due to the chemical stability of CO₂, its activation requires overcoming significant kinetic inertia and a high thermodynamic energy barrier, necessitating substantial energy input to break the C=O double bond. Artificial photosynthesis, an eco-friendly technology that mimics natural photosynthesis, converts light energy into chemical energy. Photocatalytic CO₂ reduction is the central process in artificial photosynthesis. Solar energy is abundant, freely available, renewable, and environmentally friendly. Consequently, there has been growing interest in photocatalytic CO₂ conversion. Various photocatalysts have been extensively studied over the past few decades, including metal-organic frameworks (MOFs)^[3-6], ionic liquids^[7,8], covalent organic frameworks^[9-11], core-shell nanomaterials^[12], and inorganic semiconductors such as oxides^[13-15] and sulfides^[16].

MOFs, an emerging class of crystalline materials with periodic porous structures, have attracted widespread attention in the field of photocatalysis^[4,17-19] due to their unique properties, including broad and tunable light-harvesting capacity, strong electron-hole separation ability, highly compatible and adjustable structures, uniformly dispersed and easily accessible catalytic active sites, as well as high porosity and specific surface area (SSA). However, most MOFs still suffer from certain limitations that hinder their practical applications, such as the structure collapse under strong acidic or alkaline conditions, or at elevated temperatures and pressures, along with poor water stability, limited conductivity, and inadequate chemical stability.

The UiO series of MOFs (represents the University of Oslo) exhibit significant advantages in photocatalysis due to their remarkable stability and cycling performance. The high bond energy of the Zr-O bond (~ 800 kJ·mol^-1) endows UiO-MOFs with outstanding acid resistance, water resistance, and thermal stability (up to 500 °C), which are markedly superior to those of most other MOFs^[4,20-22]. In the context of photocatalytic CO₂ reduction reaction (CO₂RR), the tunable energy band structures of UiOs make them a promising class of photocatalysts capable of modulating product selectivity with relative ease. Consequently, UiO-based materials have been extensively studied for photocatalytic CO₂RR, and substantial progress has been made in this field.

Several reviews have examined the use of UiO-66-based materials as photocatalysts for addressing environmental issues^[23] and degrading aquatic pollutants^[24], as well as the applications of UiO-67 in various fields^[25,26]. However, there is currently no review that specifically focuses on the advances of UiO-MOFs in photocatalytic CO₂RR. Therefore, this paper provides a comprehensive overview of the synthesis and modification of UiOs materials, along with recent research progress on modified UiO and their composites as photocatalysts for CO₂RR. In addition, the challenges and future prospects of UiO-based photocatalysts for CO₂RR are discussed.

2. Synthesis and Modification of UiO-MOFs

2.1 Synthesis of UiO-MOFs

The UiO series of MOFs are a class of porous materials constructed from Zr₆O₄(OH)₄ secondary building unit (SBU) and various linear dicarboxylic acid ligands, such as 1,4-benzenedicarboxylic acid (H₂BDC) for UiO-66, 4,4’-biphenyl dicarboxylic acid (BPDC) for UiO-67, and 4,4’-triphenyl dicarboxylic acid (TPDC) for UiO-68. These materials feature a three-dimensional porous framework composed of an octahedral central pore cage and eight surrounding tetrahedral corner cages^[20].

The main synthesis methods for UiO-MOFs include solvo-/hydrothermal, microwave-assisted, mechanochemical, and electrochemical approaches^[27]. Among these, the solvo-/hydrothermal method is the most commonly used and is also considered the most effective for producing high-quality UiO-MOFs. As shown in Figure 1, typical solvo-/hydrothermal synthesis involves mixing ZrCl₄ or ZrClO₄ with organic linkers, specifically H₂BDC, BPDC and TPDC, in dimethylformamide (DMF), followed by a solvothermal reaction at a specific temperature^[20,29]. The physicochemical properties of the resulting UiO materials, including morphology, particle size, and crystallinity, are significantly influenced by the reaction temperature and the addition of modulators. Although this method can yield UiO products with excellent crystallinity and well-ordered morphology, it generally requires a long time (typically 24 to 48 hours) and the use of toxic organic solvents such as DMF, along with relatively high energy consumption.

Display Full Size

Figure 1. Synthetic routes and structure diagrams of UiO-66. Republished with permission from^[23]; UiO-67. Republished with permission from^[25], and UiO-68. Republished with permission from^[28]. H₂BDC: 1,4-benzenedicarboxylic acid; BPDC: 4,4’-biphenyl dicarboxylic acid; TPDC: 4,4’-triphenyl dicarboxylic acid.

Microwave-assisted synthesis allows precise control of reaction conditions, including temperature and pressure, promotes crystal nucleation, shortens synthesis time, and enables the production of nanoscale UiO materials^[30,31]. This method is highly efficient and consumes less energy during synthesis, thereby facilitating batch production. However, it also presents challenges such as high equipment cost and limited reaction scale, which hinder its application in efficient large-scale production.

Mechanical grinding is a green synthesis method that uses little or no solvent and avoids high temperatures, strong acids, and excessive reactants, while offering high UiO yield and a short reaction time^[32]. The framework is formed either through direct grinding or via spontaneous self-assembling by mixing solid reactants and exposing them to organic vapors. This method is simple, efficient, and environmentally friendly. However, the reaction rate during mechanical grinding is difficult to control, which limits the understanding of its mechanism at the molecular level. In addition, the crystallinity, porosity, and SSA of the resulting products are generally lower than those obtained by solvothermal synthesis.

The electrochemical synthesis method uses metals as the source of metal ions, thereby effectively avoiding the influence of anions (Cl^-, NO₃^-, SO₄^2-, etc.). Under appropriate conditions of electrolyte composition, voltage, and reaction time, UiO materials synthesized by this method exhibit notable advantages, including high purity, good porosity, and uniform morphology^[33]. Additionally, it is considered one of the promising approaches for achieving continuous production of UiO-MOFs under mild reaction conditions^[34]. However, this method typically results in low yields and is prone to producing by-products.

2.2 Modification of UiO-MOFs

UiO-MOFs have demonstrated considerable potential in photocatalysis. However, pristine UiO materials typically exhibit strong ultraviolet absorption but little to no visible light response, resulting in relatively poor photocatalytic activity. Through rational design and modification, key properties such as optical response range and charge separation efficiency can be significantly improved. Generally, modification strategies for UiO-MOFs fall into two main categories: de novo synthesis and post-synthetic modification (PSM).

De novo synthesis primarily involves replacing the reagents used in the synthesis of UiO-MOFs, such as modifying the organic linkers to introduce various functional groups into the UiO frameworks^[35]. This method enables the preparation of modified UiO materials with high purity and uniform quality. It also provides considerable flexibility and controllability. By adjusting reaction parameters such as temperature, pressure, and solvent, the crystal shape, morphology, and pore structure of the resulting UiOs can be effectively tailored to meet specific application requirements. However, this approach can be challenging due to the unpredictability associated with introducing functional species, particularly those with large molecular sizes, into the UiO synthesis system.

PSM is also an effective approach to introduce functional groups into UiO-MOFs by modifying metal clusters or ligands after the initial synthesis. PSM enables the incorporation of a variety of functional moieties into the framework while preserving the original UiO structure. Through this method, UiO materials can be functionalized with various auxiliary groups and/or combined with other materials to form composites. The in situ growth method^[36,37] is commonly employed to generate UiO-based composite materials. Other approaches, such as electrostatic self-assembly^[38], microwave-assisted synthesis^[39], and ultrasonic mixing^[40], are also utilized for preparing UiO-containing composites. Compared with de novo synthesis, PSM allows for the introduction of a broader range of functional species, including those that are sensitive to or incompatible with the conditions required for constructing UiO frameworks, as well as those that might otherwise interact with undesirable sites and produce unwanted byproducts. This makes PSM a highly suitable method for tailoring and optimizing modified UiOs and their composites for specific applications. However, the distribution of functional units in materials prepared by PSM is often less uniform than that achieved through de novo synthesis.

3. Research Progress of UiO-MOFs in Photocatalytic CO₂RR

Photocatalytic CO₂RR technology enables the light-driven catalytic conversion of CO₂ into sustainable, renewable clean fuels or high value-added chemicals. Depending on the reaction pathway, different reduction products can be obtained, mainly including CO, CH₃OH, HCOOH, HCHO, and CH₄. In a photoactive MOF material, the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) level is primarily determined by the HOMO of the organic ligand, while the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) level is mainly influenced by the redox potential of the metal-oxygen cluster. As a result, oxidation and reduction reactions generally take place on the organic linker and the metal-oxygen cluster, respectively.

The LUMO and HOMO energy levels of MOFs can be precisely tuned within a narrow range. For an MOF photocatalyst to be active in CO₂ reduction, its LUMO must be at a higher energy level than the redox potential (E₀) of the corresponding CO₂ reduction half-reaction, which varies depending on the target product. For example, the E₀ for CO₂ reduction to CO is -0.53 V (vs. NHE at pH 7), while the values for reduction to HCOOH, CH₃OH and CH₄ are -0.61 V, -0.38 V and -0.24 V, respectively (Figure 2). The high degree of compositional and structural tunability of MOFs makes it possible to design photocatalysts with suitable LUMO levels to drive CO₂ reduction toward specific desired products.

Display Full Size

Figure 2. Photocatalytic CO₂ reduction over MOFs. LUMO: lowest unoccupied molecular orbital; HOMO: highest occupied molecular orbital; MOFs: metal-organic frameworks.

For most reported UiO-based photocatalysts, the primary products of photocatalytic CO₂RR are CO and HCOOH. This is mainly because the LUMO energy levels of most UiO-derived catalysts are more negative than the redox potentials (E₀) required for the reduction of CO₂ to these products. In addition, the complexity of the reaction pathways influences product selectivity. The conversion of CO₂ to CO or HCOOH involves a relatively simple two-electron transfer process, which is easier to achieve. In contrast, the formation of other single-carbon or C₂₊ requires multi-electron transfer and/or multi-step reactions, making these transformations more challenging.

Pure UiO materials exhibit poor performance in photocatalytic CO₂RR, and the main reasons are as follows: (1) pure UiOs have relatively broad band gaps and almost no visible light absorption, which limits their light utilization ability; (2) the relatively long electron transport path in pure UiO materials makes it easy for photoproduced carrier recombination; (3) pure UiO materials possess low chemical adsorption capacity for CO₂ and lack a stabilizing effect on key intermediates of CO₂RR; (4) the single surface active site of pure UiO materials sometimes cannot meet the demand for multi-step reactions and drive multi-electron transfer processes. Thus, to enhance the photocatalytic performance of UiO materials for CO₂RR, several modification methods have been developed, including (i) band-gap engineering by regulating the metal node or organic linker to adjust the position of the energy band level, (ii) defect engineering to introduce impurity energy levels and modulate the local electronic structure, (iii) introduction of metal single atoms (SAs) or nanoparticles (NPs) to boost charge separation efficiency, and (iv) combination with other photoactive semiconductors to construct interfacial built-in electric fields for facilitating the separation and migration of photoproduced carriers. These modification strategies will be discussed successively in the subsequent sections of this article.

3.1 Band-gap engineering

The photocatalytic activity of UiOs can be improved by regulating their band structures through metal node modulation or organic ligand functionalization (Figure 3). For photocatalytic CO₂RR, most studies have focused on reducing the band gaps and extending the visible-light photoresponse ranges of UiO-based materials to enhance their photocatalytic efficiency.

Display Full Size

Figure 3. Schematic diagram of two typical types of band-gap engineering of UiO-66.

3.1.1 Modulation of organic linker

Modifying the bridging linker is an effective approach to alter the energy band level positions of UiO-MOFs. The introduction of ligands with different functional groups can change the HOMO levels of UiO materials, thereby adjusting their band gap widths and physicochemical properties. For example, the presence of -CH₃ and -NH₂ groups on H₂BDC can reduce the band gap of UiO-66 to varying degrees due to their differing electron-donating abilities, which lead to different extents of upward shifts in the HOMO level^[41]. Specifically, substitution -NH₂ and -CH₃ groups can reduce the band gap of hcp UiO-66 (originally 4.07 eV) to 2.92 eV and 3.93 eV, respectively. In contrast, -COOH functionalization increases the band gap^[42], limiting the optical response of the material to the ultraviolet region. As shown in Figure 4, a variety of linkers have been employed in the syntheses of UiO derivatives.

Display Full Size

Figure 4. Different organic linkers used to synthesize UiO-MOFs or modified after synthesis. MOFs: metal-organic frameworks.

Light-harvesting modification of UiOs began with the work of Silva et al.^[43], which demonstrated that the presence of -NH₂ groups on the linker in UiO-66 extended its absorption spectrum into the visible light region, thereby enhancing its photocatalytic performance for the hydrogen evolution reaction. In addition, it has been well established that the light-harvesting capability can be further improved by increasing the number of functional groups in the ligand or by using mixed linkers. Sun et al.^[44] synthesized a mixture of NH₂-UiO-66 and 2,5-NH₂-UiO-66 using organic linkers containing one and two -NH₂ groups (1 and 2), which exhibited showed higher photocatalytic CO₂ reduction activity toward HCOOH (41.4 μmol·g^-1·h^-1) compared to pure NH₂-UiO-66. This improvement was mainly attributed to the enhanced light absorption and CO₂ adsorption resulting from the presence of additional -NH₂ groups.

UiO-66-X₂ (X = -SH, -SCH₃, -SO₃H) synthesized by modifying H₂BDC with different sulfur-containing groups (compounds 3 to 5), exhibited significantly increased band edge wavelengths in the range of 425~470 nm compared with pure UiO-66 (320 nm). This enhancement was found to depend on the electron-donating ability, geometry, and size of the functional group^[45]. Among these, -SCH₃ was the most effective, and UiO-66-(SCH₃)₂ showed a markedly reduced band gap (2.80 eV vs. 4.07 eV for UiO-66) along with improved photocatalytic performance. In addition, it has been demonstrated that introducing -OH and double -OH groups (compounds 6 and 7) into UiO-66 can also reduce its band gap to 2.2 eV^[46]. Wang et al.^[47] prepared three functionalized UiO-67 materials using different ligands (compounds 8 to 10). Without the use of any organic solvents or sacrificial agents, UiO-67-o-(CH₃)₂ exhibited an excellent CO yield for photocatalytic CO₂RR, reaching 178 μmol·g^-1·h^-1. This enhancement can be attributed to the fact that, compared with the -CF₃ group, the -CH₃ group increases CO₂ adsorption capacity and reduction potential while facilitating the separation and transfer of photogenerated charge carriers.

In addition to the direct synthesis of UiO-MOFs using functional bridging ligands, a PSM approach can also be employed to introduce functional species onto the linkers of UiO materials. Three UiO-68 MOFs with F-, CH₃- and OCH₃- functionalized linkers (compounds 11 to 13) were prepared via amine-aldehyde condensation of UiO-68-NH₂ with 3-fluorobenzaldehyde, 3-methylbenzaldehyde, and 3-methoxybenzaldehyde, respectively^[48]. These materials showed varying photocatalytic performance for CO₂RR toward CO due to differences in charge separation and band gap characteristics. Among them, UiO-68-OCH₃, containing an electron-donating group, exhibited the best catalytic ability, achieving a CO production rate of 118.12 μmol·g^-1·h^-1 under visible light irradiation.

In short, introducing functional groups into the organic ligands of UiOs influences their charge separation efficiency, light-harvesting ability, and electron density around the metal nodes. In particular, increasing the electron density through electron-donating groups can reduce the band gap energy of UiO materials and enhance their absorption in the visible light range, thereby significantly improving their photocatalytic performance. However, the enhancement effect of functional group introduction on linker-to-metal charge-transfer (LMCT) excitation is limited, and the variety of applicable substituents remains restricted.

3.1.2 Modulation of metal nodes

Modulation of metal centers is another effective strategy to alter the energy band level positions of UiO materials. Constructing mixed-metal nodes in UiO-MOFs through metal substitution can introduce intermetallic charge transfer and enhance optical properties, thereby improving photocatalytic performance. By partially or fully replacing Zr metal nodes with other metals such as Ti^[49-51], Ce^[52], Cu^[53], and Hf^[54], electron transfer between the different metal centers can be facilitated. This modification lowers the E₀ of the metal center, narrow the effective band gap of UiO materials, and enhances charge separation efficiency^[49].

Sun et al.^[50] prepared a Ti-substituted UiO material, NH₂-UiO-66(Zr/Ti), via a post-synthetic exchange (PSE) treatment. This material exhibited enhanced photocatalytic activity for CO₂RR toward HCOOH, achieving a yield of 580 μmol·mol^-1·h^-1 under visible light (420 ~ 800 nm), compared with 340 μmol·mol^-1·h^-1 for the unsubstituted analogue. Electron spin resonance characterization and density functional theory (DFT) calculations confirmed that Ti atoms contributed significantly to the bottom of the conduction band (CB) in the modified catalyst, promoting Ti-mediated electron migration from the 2-aminoterephthalic acid linker to the Zr center, thereby improving catalytic performance (Figure 5a). Subsequently, a mixed-ligand and mixed-metal UiO-66 material was also synthesized via the PSE method and applied as a photocatalyst for CO₂RR^[51]. Similarly, results indicated that the presence of the Ti moiety was essential for the visible-light-driven photocatalytic CO₂RR, as it enabled the metal nodes to accept electrons from the ligands. In addition, the use of a mixed ligand system consisting of 2-amino- and 2,5-diaminoterephthalic acid further enhanced the photocatalytic performance of the UiO catalyst by introducing new energy levels, thereby broadening the optical response range and facilitating charge migration.

Display Full Size

Figure 5. (a) Photocatalytic CO₂RR mechanism over Ti modified NH₂-UiO-66. Republished with permission from^[50]; (b) Schematic diagram for the synthesis of Cu modified UiO-67. Republished with permission from^[53]. ATA: 2-aminoterephthalic acid; CO₂RR: CO₂reduction reaction.

Cu has also been employed to modify the metal nodes of UiO-67. Bimetallic UiO-67-(Zr/Cu) materials were prepared by in situ anchoring of Cu atoms onto the Zr clusters of linker-defective UiO-67 (Figure 5b)^[53]. Experimental results demonstrated that the formation of Zr-O-Cu sites effectively promoted CO₂ adsorption, charge migration, and charge separation. Moreover, the bimetallic synergistic effect facilitated the generation of C₂ intermediates during the CO₂RR. As a result, the optimized catalyst with a Cu loading of 2 wt% exhibited excellent photocatalytic activity (69.1 μmol·g^-1·h^-1) and 100% selectivity for the conversion of CO₂RR to C₂H₄ under visible-light irradiation.

In addition to PSE, an in situ metal exchange process was also employed to fabricate a Ti-modified NH₂-UiO-66 material^[49]. A decrease in band gap was observed for both catalysts synthesized via post-synthetic and in situ metal exchange methods. Despite differences in synthesis routes and Ti loadings, both catalysts exhibited significantly enhanced photocatalytic performance for CO₂RR toward HCOOH production, attributed to their broadened light absorption range, which was nearly twice that of unmodified NH₂-UiO-66. Beyond monometallic substitution, multimetallic UiO-66 materials incorporating Ce, Ti and Zr were also developed for the selective photocatalytic methanation of CO₂ under simulated sunlight, using RuOx as co-catalyst^[52]. It was found that the Zr/Ce/Ti-UiO-66 catalyst outperformed monometallic Zr- and Ce-UiO-66, as well as bimetallic Zr/Ce- and Zr/Ti-UiO-66, achieving a CH₄ production rate of 1,900 μmol·g^-1 after 22 hours of photoreaction. Spectroscopic characterization and photocatalytic experiments confirmed that the excellent activity was due to a dual photothermal and photochemical mechanism.

In the Zr₆SBUs of UiO materials, partially or completely replacing the Zr metal nodes with other metal ions is an effective strategy to shift the band edge and band gap position, modify the hybrid energy levels between the SBU and the organic ligand, and achieve electron localization at the metal center.

3.2 Defect engineering

Defects in MOF materials are generally classified into two categories: metal defects and ligand defects (Figure 6). Metal defects typically result from the absence of metal nodes or the partial replacement of metal ions by others metal species. Ligand defects, on the other hand, often arise from the absence of organic linkers or the substitution of linkers with other molecules. It is widely accepted that the crystal structure determines the properties of materials, and the formation of structural defects is usually accompanied by bond breakage and recombination, lattice deformation, and electron localization^[55]. These microstructure changes caused by defect engineering can either alter the original properties or impart new functionalities to the materials. In addition, the formation of surface defects and internal nanopores also facilitates molecular adsorption^[56]. Defect engineering therefore provides an efficient strategy to regulate the physicochemical properties of MOFs, including their stability, adsorption capacity, and catalytic performance^[57]. Moreover, defects can act as active sites and promote the separation of electrons and holes^[58]. As such, defect engineering is considered an effective method for tuning the band structure and electronic properties, and for customizing the functionalities of MOF materials^[59].

Display Full Size

Figure 6. Schematic diagram of two typical types of UiO defects.

In the case of UiO series of MOFs, the strong chemical bonds between Zr and oxygen atoms, as well as the high coordination of each Zr₆SBU with 12 organic linkers, make these materials highly tolerant to structural defect modulation. Defects in UiO materials generally arise from the absence of ligands and/or Zr-O clusters during the nucleation or PSM process. For UiO-66, it has been shown that the framework structure can be maintained even when each Zr-O cluster lacks up to 4.3 organic linker ligands^[60]. The main strategies for introducing structural defects in UiOs include the following: (a) Replacement of Zr precursor: Using ZrOCl₂·8H₂O instead of ZrCl₄ allows competition between the dicarboxylate organic linker and water molecules in ZrOCl₂·8H₂O^[61], thereby reducing coordination between the Zr cluster and the ligand. (b) Solvent-free synthesis^[62]: This method reduces the solubility of organic linkers, leading to coordination discrepancies between clusters and ligands. (c) Use of modulators^[63,64]: Monocarboxylic acids such as HCOOH, benzoic acid, CH₃COOH, and CF₃COOH can act as modulators, forming defects in UiO frameworks through various mechanisms, including inducing ligand deficiency via competitive coordination, etching the lattice through chemical reactions, and regulating crystallization dynamics by altering the reaction environment. (d) Introduction of competitive metal precursors: This approach can form mixed-metal nodes and Zr₆ cluster-missing defects, such as introducing six-coordinated Ti in place of some octa-coordinated Zr ions^[61]. (e) PSE^[65]: Through solvent-assisted ligand exchange, specific species can be anchored at defect sites generated by modulator-induced competitive coordination, enabling the synthesis of UiO materials with diverse functional groups and characteristics.

Defect structures have a significant impact on the photocatalytic performance of UiOs. Wang et al.^[63] synthesized several UiO materials, denoted as UiO-6X-NH₂ (X = 6, 7, and 8), containing different dicarboxylate linkers and NH ₂-modified defects, and evaluated them for photocatalytic CO₂RR. Among them, the 3,5-diamino-benzoate-modulated NH₂-UiO-66 exhibited the highest catalytic activity for CO production (17.5 μmol·g ^-1·h^-1), attributed to its lowest absorption energy (E_abs), achieving 2.4 times the activity of benzoate-modulated UiO-68-NH₂. Subsequently, the authors prepared a series of UiO-66-NH₂-X materials with defect types, including ligand vacancy defects (X = LV), missing-cluster defects (X = MC), and linker defects compensated by CH₃COOH and HCOOH (X = AA and FA, respectively) (Figure 7a). Theoretical calculation and experimental results confirmed that UiO-NH₂-LV exhibited the best photocatalytic CO₂RR activity among the four, with a CO yield of 30.5 μmol·g^-1·h^-1, which was 9.2 times higher than that of UiO-66-NH₂-MC (Figure 7b). DFT calculations revealed that the presence of defects would adjust the values of LMCT energy (E_LMCT) and E_abs during photocatalysis, thereby resulting in different photocatalytic activities over these UiO-66 derivatives. UiO-NH₂-LV possessed the smallest sum of E_LMCT and E_abs, which effectively reduced the energy barrier in the rate-controlling step of CO₂ reduction. Furthermore, UiO-66-NH₂-LV demonstrated excellent stability and recyclability, maintaining its catalytic activity over six consecutive reaction cycles (Figure 7c).

Display Full Size

Figure 7. (a) Different defect synthesis routes of UiO-66-NH₂; (b) Photocatalytic performance of various catalysts and (c) Cyclic experiments of UiO-66-NH₂-LV. Republished with permission from^[64].

In addition to defect type, the degree of ligand vacancies in UiOs materials can also influence their photocatalytic activity. It has been found that a greater number of ligand vacancies per metal node in UiO-66 leads to a lower E_LMCT, resulting in enhanced CO evolution^[66]. A series of UiO-67 materials with varying numbers of linker defects were synthesized by adjusting the amount of HCOOH used during synthesis, and they exhibited different photocatalytic CO₂ reduction activities^[67]. Among them, the catalyst UiO-67-200 showed the best catalytic performance for converting CO₂ to CO, achieving a yield of 12.29 μmol·g^-1·h^-1, which was 5.25 times that of UiO-67-0. These results demonstrated that an appropriate level of linker defects can enhance the separation efficiency of charge carriers and promote LMCT.

By altering the synthesis temperature, several types of defective NH₂-UiO-66 materials were prepared using HCl as a modulating agent and applied as photocatalysts for CO₂RR^[57]. Compared with non-defective NH₂-UiO-66, these defective catalysts exhibited significantly enhanced photocatalytic activity, with a maximum HCOOH production rate of 129.8 μmol·g^-1·h^-1. The improved catalytic performance was attributed to the more open framework structure and the increased number of active sites generated through defect engineering, which facilitated the transfer of photogenerated charge carriers.

In summary, defect engineering, achieved by adding modulators, adjusting synthesis temperatures, and altering synthesis precursors, can create more open frameworks and increase the number of active binding sites in UiO-MOFs. As a result, it can effectively accelerate photoinduced charge transfer and suppress the recombination of photogenerated charge carriers, thereby enhancing the photocatalytic CO₂ reduction capacity of UiO materials.

3.3 Introduction of metal species

In recent years, numerous studies have focused on enhancing the photocatalytic performance of UiO-MOFs by doping or loading metal species into UiOs (Figure 8). Introducing metal components enables both metal-to-metal and metal-to-cluster charge transfer, providing an effective strategy to expand the light absorption range and improve charge separation efficiency, thereby enhancing the overall photocatalytic performance of UiO catalysts.

Display Full Size

Figure 8. Schematic diagram of the modification of UiO-66 with metal species. SAs: single atoms; NPs: nanoparticles.

3.3.1 Introduction of metal single-atom site

Single-atom catalysts have attracted significant attention due to the unsaturated coordination environment and unique electronic structure of atomically dispersed active sites. These catalysts enable high atomic utilization and provide abundant photocatalytic active sites. Anchoring metal SAs onto the surface of UiO materials is considered an effective approach to address the issue of insufficient photogenerated charge separation. Moreover, the incorporation of single-atomic sites into UiOs can introduce additional photocatalytic active sites and facilitate charge transfer, thereby enhancing overall photocatalytic performance. Fe-, Co-, Ni-, and Cu-based single-atom catalysts have been widely studied for photocatalytic CO₂RR, as their unfilled 3d orbitals can efficiently accelerate the transfer of photogenerated charges in the system^[68]. It is important to note that these metal sites introduced into UiOs do not form part of the metal nodes. Instead, they are located on the surface or are chemically bonded to the organic linkers or Zr-oxygen clusters.

A photoinduction method was developed by Wang et al.^[69] to anchor Cu SAs onto the -NH₂ moieties of NH₂-UiO-66 (Figure 9a). Compared with pristine NH₂-UiO-66 and the Cu NPs/NH₂-UiO-66 composite, the synthesized Cu SAs/NH₂-UiO-66 exhibited significantly enhanced visible-light photocatalytic performance for CO₂RR, producing CH₃OH and C₂H₅OH at rates of 5.33 and 4.22 μmol·g^-1·h^-1, respectively. This high catalytic activity was attributed to the introduction of Cu SAs, which facilitated electron enrichment on the catalyst surface and improved photogenerated charge separation. Similarly, Zn SAs were anchored onto NH₂-UiO-66, and the resulting catalyst demonstrated excellent activity for the reduction of CO₂ to CO^[70]. In another study, the photocatalytic performance of Bipy-UiO-67 was enhanced by incorporating Co SAs. The modified catalyst exhibited improved CO₂ adsorption capacity and CO evolution efficiency for photocatalytic CO₂RR compared to the pristine Bipy-UiO-67^[71].

Display Full Size

Figure 9. (a) Synthesis procedure of Cu SAs/NH₂-UiO-66. Republished with permission from^[69]; (b) Synthesis procedure of Co- and Re-UiO-67. Republished with permission from^[75].

Using UiO-66-(OH)₂ as the structural precursor, single-atomic Co²⁺ sites were anchored onto the Zr-O nodes of metal-organic-layer nanocages synthesized via a cosolvent approach^[72]. The photocatalytic performance of the resulting catalyst was evaluated for CO₂RR and showed an exceptionally high CO production rate of 7,740 μmol·g^-1·h^-1, along with excellent stability, maintaining 97.1% product retention after five cycles. This outstanding photocatalytic activity was primarily attributed to the unique nanocage structure, which facilitated greater exposure of Co²⁺ sites through the large-area 2D UiO-66-based nanosheets and enhanced local CO₂ due to the presence of abundant surface hydroxyl groups.

In addition to metal SAs, incorporating metal complexes into UiOs is also an effective strategy to introduce isolated metal sites and enhance catalytic activity. Re(CO)₃Cl-modified UiO-67^[73] was synthesized using a rhenium complex bearing dicarboxylic acid functionality and applied in photocatalytic CO₂RR to produce CO, achieving a high turnover number of 10.9, which was three times that of the homogeneous Re complex. Four types of half-sandwich Ru and Rh molecular complexes were incorporated into UiO-67 frameworks via a PSE strategy and used as photocatalysts for CO₂RR^[74]. It was demonstrated that catalysts containing Rh-OH₂ or Ru-OH₂ exhibited superior catalytic activity compared to those containing Rh-Cl or Ru-Cl. Two metal ion-doped UiO catalysts, Re-UiO-67 and Co-UiO-67, were synthesized through a combined solvothermal and post-metallization strategy (Figure 9b)^[75]. Both UiO-67-based MOFs showed significantly higher CO₂ adsorption capacities compared to the pristine material. Among them, Co-UiO-67 exhibited much higher photocatalytic activity for CO₂RR with a CO evolution rate of 3,292.5 μmol·g^-1·h^-1, in contrast to 412.5 μmol·g^-1·h^-1 for Re-UiO-67. This superior performance was attributed to the enhanced charge transport properties of Co-UiO-67 and the unsaturated coordination of its Co active sites, which improved CO₂ adsorption capacity.

To investigate the role of the coordination environment around single metal sites in photocatalysis, UiO-Co-N_x (x = 2, 3, 4) catalysts with different numbers of coordinated N atom numbers around Co sites were synthesized based on the UiO-67-20% material that was obtained by a mixed-ligand strategy with 20% H₂bpydc and 80% H₂bpdc^[76]. Among these catalysts, UiO-Co-N₃ exhibited the highest photocatalytic performance for CO₂ conversion to CO. This superior activity was attributed to its fast charge transfer dynamics and the low electronic density of Co(II) sites, which resulted in reduced energy barriers for CO₂RR.

The unique structural tunability of UiOs makes them an ideal platform for the introduction of catalytic single metal sites and the precise modulation of their coordination microenvironment, thereby enabling excellent photocatalytic performance for CO₂ reduction.

3.3.2 Introduction of metal NPs

In photocatalytic reactions, metal NPs introduced into UiOs can not only enhance absorption in the visible-light spectrum but also serve as electron acceptors and active sites. Certain metal NPs, such as Au, Ag, and Cu, can broaden the optical response range through localized surface plasmon resonance (LSPR) when confined with nanoscale UiO particles. In particular, the collective oscillation of electrons on the surface of these metals, when restricted within a nanoscale cage, may give rise to characteristic optical response bands.

The Au/NH₂-UiO-66/graphene (GR) catalyst was synthesized by co-modifying NH₂-UiO-66 with Au NPs and GR^[77]. Although the Au particles exhibited a wide size distribution (3 ~ 33 nm), the catalyst still demonstrated higher photocatalytic CO₂ reduction activity and greater selectivity toward HCOOH compared to NH₂-UiO-66/GR and pristine NH₂-UiO-66. This improvement was attributed to the LSPR effect of the Au NPs, which enhanced visible light absorption, and the excellent conductivity of GR sheets, which helped suppress the recombination of photogenerated electron-hole pairs.

In addition, the spatial position of precious metal NPs relative to UiOs has a significant impact on photocatalytic efficiency. Two modified NH₂-UiO-66 materials, with Pt NPs located on the surface and inside the nanochannels, namely Pt/NH₂-UiO-66 and Pt@NH₂-UiO-66 respectively, both exhibited superior photocatalytic performance compared to pristine NH₂-UiO-66^[78]. Notably, Pt@NH₂-UiO-66 showed approximately five times the efficiency of Pt/NH₂-UiO-66, primarily due to its shortened electron migration distance, which facilitated the separation of photogenerated electron and hole pairs. Similarly, a series of hybrids incorporating Pt NPs (approximately 4 nm in size) in different positions, interior, exterior, or both interior and exterior, of flower-like NH₂-UiO-68 were synthesized using various preparation methods and Pt loadings (Figure 10)^[79]. Among them, Pt(2)@NH₂-UiO-68, with 2 wt% Pt loaded inside the porous framework, exhibited the highest visible-light photocatalytic activity for the conversion of CO₂ to CO. These results demonstrated that proper positioning and loading of Pt NPs within the catalyst can enhance their interaction with NH₂-UiO-68 and facilitate charge transfer during the photocatalytic process.

Display Full Size

Figure 10. Synthesis procedures of various Pt NP-loaded UiO-68 catalysts. Republished with permission from^[79]. NPs: nanoparticles.

Furthermore, the size of metal NPs also has a significant impact on catalytic efficiency. Four Ag@UiO-66 catalysts with varying sizes and loading of Ag NPs were prepared via in situ growth of Ag NPs within the nanopores of SH-functionalized UiO-66^[80]. The Ag loadings on these catalysts were 8.32%, 23.27%, 39.79%, and 51.20%, with corresponding Ag NP sizes of 1.06 nm, 1.9 nm, 2.0 nm, and 5.0 nm, respectively. Photocatalytic tests showed that the catalytic activities of Ag@UiO-66 followed a volcano-type trend as the size of Ag NPs increased. The catalyst with an average Ag particle size of 2.0 nm and a loading of 39.79% exhibited the best activity for photocatalytic CO₂RR to produce CO as well as a small amount of hydrocarbons, due mainly to its good balance in Ag loading and mass transfer within the nanochannels.

Beyond noble metals, non-noble metal NPs have also been introduced into UiOs for photocatalytic CO₂RR. Several Co-decorated NH₂-UiO-66 catalysts with varying Co loadings were synthesized by post-synthetic NaBH₄ treatment^[81]. The catalyst with 5wt% Co loading showed the most prominent photocatalytic activity for CO₂RR, with a CO evolution rate of 1,930 μmol·g^-1·h^-1, which was 10.2 times that of the unmodified catalyst. This high catalytic performance was mainly due to the high dispersion of Co on the catalyst surface, which accelerated charge transfer and separation during catalysis. Six types of metal NPs, namely Au, Cu, Ag, Pt, Pd, and Ni, were supported onto UiO-66 as photocatalysts for CO₂RR^[82]. The integration of Au and Cu NPs into UiO-66 obviously boosted the catalytic performance of CO₂ reduction to CH₃OH and C₂H₅OH. It was because of the incorporation of metal NPs that leads to the LSPR, thus promoting the light absorption capacity, efficient charge dynamics, charge separation efficiency, as well as the production of electron-hole pairs.

As it turns out, introducing metal NPs into UiO-MOFs can enhance their photocatalytic performance by improving visible light absorption, promoting charge transfer during photocatalysis, or inhibiting the recombination of electron-hole pairs. However, the types of metal NPs introduced into UiO materials remain limited, and most of them are precious metal NPs. Therefore, it is necessary to continue developing more suitable materials to serve as co-catalysts.

3.4 Combination with other materials

Due to the high carrier transport resistance, low structure order, and narrow band gap of UiO materials, the separation efficiency, transfer efficiency, and adsorption capacity of photogenerated charges in pristine UiOs are far from ideal. As a result, extensive research has focused on enhancing the photocatalytic performance of UiOs by combining them with other materials, such as sulphides^[37,83], lead-free halides^[84-86], and other MOFs^[87]. Compared with single-component catalysts, constructing composite photocatalysts offers several potential advantages. First, the introduced photoactive semiconductor can serve as a light-harvesting center to improve solar energy utilization. Second, the UiO component, with its high porosity and SSA, can provide active sites and prevent the aggregation of external NPs. Third, the formation of tight interfacial connections between the photoactive semiconductor and UiO can create effective pathways for the migration and separation of photogenerated charges.

3.4.1 As co-catalysts for photocatalytic CO₂RR

In some studies, UiOs have been combined with other photocatalysts and used as co-catalysts. The primary functions of UiOs as co-catalysts in photocatalysis include providing a robust scaffold to support and stabilize other photocatalysts, as well as offering a high SSA for the adsorption of reactants. For example, a composite photocatalyst, Ni@Ru-UiO-67, with visible-light response was fabricated by encapsulating a Ni(II) molecular catalyst into Ru-UiO-67 via a “ship-in-a-bottle” strategy^[88]. This composite exhibited excellent catalytic activity, selectivity, and durability for photocatalytic CO₂RR toward CO. The high performance was attributed to the efficient transfer of photoelectrons generated by the Ru centers to the Ni(II) active sites. Tan et al.^[89] synthesized a soluble UiO-66(NH₄OH) and applied it as a co-catalyst for photocatalytic CO₂RR to CO. The resulting CO yield reached 30.6 μmol·h^-1 with 5.0 mg sample, which was 1.5 times higher than that of its insoluble analogue.

3.4.2 Construction of heterojunctions

Constructing heterojunctions has proven to be a highly promising strategy for modifying UiOs to enhance their photocatalytic properties, owing to its simplicity, feasibility, and high efficiency in facilitating the separation of photogenerated electron-hole pairs. Extensive research has been devoted to combining UiO-MOFs with other materials through various methods to construct heterojunctions, and significant progress has been made in this area^[37,90]. Based on current studies on UiO heterojunction modification, three types of heterojunctions have been developed: type-II, Z-scheme, and S-scheme.

A type-II heterojunction consists of two staggered semiconductors (PS-I and PS-II). As shown in Figure 11a, PS-II possesses a lower oxidation potential and a higher reduction potential compared to PS-I. Under appropriate light excitation, photogenerated electron-hole pairs are produced under suitable light excitation. Electrons transfer from the CB of PS-II to the CB of PS-I, while holes move in the opposite direction, resulting in the effective separation of photoinduced electron-hole pairs. Table 1 summarizes relevant studies on UiO-based type-II heterojunction materials for photocatalytic CO₂RR conducted over the past five years.

Display Full Size

Figure 11. (a) Schematic diagram of type-II heterojunction; (b) Mechanism for BiOBr/NH₂-UiO-66 heterostructure. Republished with permission from^[85]; (c) Charge separation mechanism for NH₂-UiO-66@MIL-101. Republished with permission from^[89].

Some quantum dot (QD) materials, such as Cs₂AgBiBr₆^[86] and CsPbBr₃^[91], have been combine with UiO-66 and its derivatives to construct type-II heterojunction photocatalysts. These composites exhibited significantly enhanced photocatalytic efficiency for CO₂ reduction, primarily yielding CO, due to rapid charge separation and transfer at the interface. In particular, the Cs₂AgBiBr₆/Ce-UiO-66-H composite achieved a high CO generation rate of 309.01 μmol·g^-1·h^-1, which was approximately 2.7 and 2.1 times greater than those of pristine Ce-UiO-66-H and Cs₂AgBiBr₆, respectively^[86]. This outstanding catalytic activity can be attributed to the following factors: (i) the close interfacial contact inhibited the ‌agglomeration and decomposition of Cs₂AgBiBr₆QDs; (ii) more structural defects were introduced into the Ce-UiO-66-H framework by Cs₂AgBiBr₆; and (iii) good band alignment and high electron mobility promoted efficient charge separation. It can be seen that the combination of halide QDs and UiO-MOFs is conducive to the dispersion of QDs, and the constructed compact heterojunction contact surface improves electron mobility and carrier separation efficiency, thus achieving better performance in photocatalytic CO₂RR.

To improve the electron-hole separation ability of BiOBr, type-II heterojunctions BiOBr/NH₂-UiO-66 containing Lewis basic moieties were constructed by depositing NH₂-UiO-66 onto BiOBr (Figure 11b)^[85]. These composites exhibited high CO yields up to 9.19 μmol·g^-1·h^-1 in photocatalytic CO₂RR, which was four times that of pure BiOBr. Liu et al.^[92] synthesized a composite, Cu SAs@PCN@UiO, by confining polymeric carbon nitride (PCN) with Cu SAs inside defective NH₂-UiO-66 nanocrystals using a straightforward low-temperature thermolysis method. Cu SAs@PCN@UiO exhibited high activity for photocatalytic CO₂ conversion to CH₃OH, with a remarkably high product yield of 4,150 μmol·g^-1·h^-1, along with small amounts of CH₃CH₂OH and trace CH₄. It was demonstrated that both the doping of Cu SAs and the formation of heterojunction between the UiO shell and the incapsulated Cu SAs@PCN contributed to the highly efficient generation of CH₃OH.

Some double MOF-based type-II heterojunctions have been developed. A type-II heterojunction material, NH₂-UiO-66@MIL-101, was fabricated via a solvothermal approach by depositing nanoscale NH₂-UiO-66 onto MIL-101^[87]. The resulting heterostructure enhanced the separation of photogenerated charges and facilitated interfacial electron migration (Figure 11c). As a result, the composite exhibited superior photocatalytic activity for CO₂RR compared with both pristine MOF components, achieving CO and CH₄ production rates of 267.90 and 18.63 μmol·g^-1·h^-1, respectively. These rates were more than three times those of MIL-101(Cr) and approximately 5.75 times those of NH₂-UiO-66. Three types of core-shell heterostructures were constructed by loading UiO-66 onto MIL-125 with different exposed crystal planes via an epitaxial growth strategy^[93]. Among them, MIL-125_to@UiO-66 exposing {111} crystal plane showed the highest CO formation rate, reaching 56.4 μmol·g^-1·h^-1, along with excellent selectivity (99%) for visible-light photocatalytic CO₂RR without the need for a photosensitizer or sacrificial reagent. These values were 11.3 and 1.4 times those of pure UiO-66 and MIL-125_to, respectively. This outstanding catalytic performance was attributed to the improved separation of photoproduced carrier separation via the type-II heterostructure and the exposure of more active Ti sites on MIL-125_to@UiO-66.

Some studies have combined UiO-MOFs with g-C₃N₄ for catalyst modification to reduce quenching of photoproduced charge carriers and improve sunlight utilization efficiency^[94]. A 2D g-C₃N₄/UiO-66(Zr/Ce) composite with a type-II heterostructure was synthesized through a solvothermal method, using g-C₃N₄ supported Zr and Ce SAs as metal sources of UiO-66 nanosheets, forming interfacial N-Zr/Ce-O bonds^[95]. Under visible light, this composite efficiently catalyzed CO₂RR to produce CH₃OH and C₂H₅OH, with evolution rates of 54.71 and 38.10 μmol·g^-1·h^-1, respectively. This high catalytic activity was attributed to the facilitated delocalization and migration of photoelectrons from the conjugated π structure of g-C₃N₄ to UiO-66 via the N-Zr/Ce-O bonds. Additionally, the strong coordination interaction between the two materials endowed the composite photocatalyst with excellent stability during photocatalytic CO₂RR, maintaining catalytic activity after 12 cycles.

Although type-II heterojunctions can to some extent enhance the separation efficiency of photogenerated electron-hole pairs, they often sacrifice the high redox capability of photocatalysts, resulting in unsatisfactory photocatalytic performance. To address this challenge, Z-scheme heterojunctions have been introduced. Under light irradiation, as illustrated in Figure 12a, electrons in the valence band (VB) in PS-I are first excited to its CB, and then migrate to the VB of PS-II. Consequently, photoproduced electrons and holes accumulate in PS-II and PS-I, respectively, which possess higher reduction and oxidation potentials. This process not only promotes effective separation of photoproduced electron-hole pairs but also optimizes the redox potential. Relevant studies on UiO-based Z-scheme heterostructure materials for photocatalytic CO₂RR over the past five years are summarized in Table 2.

Display Full Size

Figure 12. (a) Schematic diagram of Z-scheme heterojunction; (b) Illustration of the photocatalytic CO₂RR over NH₂-UiO-66/Cu₂O/Cu. Republished with permission from^[101]; (c) Energy level structures of NH₂-UiO-66 and MoS, and (d) depiction of the synthesis of f-MoS₂@NH₂-UiO-66. Republished with permission from^[102]; (e) Schematic diagram of electron migration in the Z-scheme heterojunction NH₂-UiO-66@Pro-COF-Br. Republished with permission from^[103]. CO₂RR: CO₂ reduction reaction; CB: conduction band; VB: valence band.

The NH₂-UiO-66/Cu₂O/Cu material with an indirect Z-scheme heterostructure was constructed by coupling Cu₂O with NH₂-UiO-66 for photocatalytic CO₂ conversion to CO^[101]. This composite achieved CO production rates of up to 4.54 μmol·g^-1·h^-1, which were 37.8 and 50.4 times higher than those of NH₂-UiO-66 and Cu₂O, respectively. The superior photocatalytic performance was attributed to the effective formation of the Z-scheme heterostructure (Figure 12b), in which NH₂-UiO-66 prevents Cu₂O from photocorrosion and enhances CO₂ adsorption capacity, while Cu acts as a mediator to promote electron transfer and provides active sites.

Several Z-scheme heterojunctions, MoS₂@NH₂-UiO-66, were synthesized by combining MoS₂ with different morphologies and NH₂-UiO-66 with varying grain sizes, and were applied for photocatalytic CO₂ reduction^[102]. Among them, the flower-like composite based on 100 nm NH₂-UiO-66, as shown in Figure 12c,d, exhibited the best photocatalytic performance due to its well-matched micro-geometric configuration. It achieved a CH₄ yield of 27.18 μmol·g^-1·h^-1 and a selectivity of 82.44%. This excellent catalytic activity can be attributed to the intimate heterointerface between the small-size NH₂-UiO-66 and the flower-like MoS₂, which possesses superior basal plane curvature. This configuration significantly increased the contact barrier and promoted interfacial charge transfer.

A type of core-shell Z-scheme heterojunctions NH₂-UiO-66@Pro-COF-Br, was constructed by in situ growth method via the Schiff-base reaction^[103]. In these hybrid materials, the porphyrin units on the Pro-COF-Br shell functioned as light-harvesting centers, greatly extending the light absorption range. At the same time, the formed Z-scheme heterostructure and the C=N bonds acted as bridges to significantly enhance charge migration and separation (Figure 12e). As a result, these composites exhibited excellent catalytic performance for CO₂RR under visible light, achieving CO production rates up to 26.59 μmol·g^-1·h^-1.

In addition to single heterostructure, double Z-scheme heterojunctions have also been also constructed and applied for photocatalytic CO₂RR. A catalyst with double Z-scheme heterojunctions was prepared by hand-grinding CdS/Ag-AgBr nanocrystals with Au-supported NH ₂-defective UiO-66(Ce), and employed for the photocatalytic CO₂RR to produce CH₃OH^[104]. The CH₃OH yield over this catalyst reached 1,939 μmol·g^-1 within 4 h, which was approximately 5 times and 4.4 times higher than those achieved by the single Z-scheme heterojunction systems of Au-supported NH₂-defective UiO-66(Ce) and CdS/Ag-AgBr, respectively.

Based on the concept of the direct Z-scheme heterojunction, the S-scheme heterojunction was proposed to address charge transfer limitations in type-II and conventional Z-scheme heterojunctions. An S-scheme heterojunction is composed of a reduction photocatalyst (RP) and an oxidation photocatalyst (OP) with staggered band structure (Figure 13a)^[113]. When RP comes into contact with OP, electrons from the RP migrate to the OP at the interface, resulting in the RP and OP sides becoming positively and negatively charged, respectively. Meanwhile, the interface between OP and RP forms downward or upward band bending and a built-in electric field that drives the transfer of photoproduced electrons from the CB in the OP to the VB of the RP. In addition, the band bending and Coulombic attraction between holes in the RP and electrons in the OP further promote this charge migration. In contrast, the built-in electric field, band bending, and Coulombic repulsion inhibit the migration of electrons from the CB of the RP to that of the OP, as well as the movement of holes from the VB of the OP to that of the RP. As a result, the S-scheme heterostructure enables both efficient charge separation and strong redox capacity, thereby enhancing photocatalytic performance. Table 3 summarizes recent studies on UiO-based S-scheme heterojunction materials for photocatalytic CO₂RR over the past five years.

Display Full Size

Figure 13. (a) Charge migration processes in an S-scheme heterostructure. Republished with permission from^[113]; (b) Mechanism of visible light photocatalytic CO₂RR over Ce/Zr-NH₂-UiO-66/CdIn₂S₄. Republished with permission from^[114]; (c) Mechanism of photocatalytic CO₂RR over NH₂-UiO-66/RGO and the corresponding differential charge density. Republished with permission from^[115]. CO₂RR: CO₂ reduction reaction; CB: conduction band; VB: valence band; OP: oxidation photocatalyst; RP: reduction photocatalyst.

A type of S-scheme heterojunction, Ce/Zr-NH₂-UiO-66/CdIn₂S₄ with varying Ce contents, was synthesized by modifying NH₂-UiO-66(Ce/Zr) with CdIn₂S₄ through an in situ hydrothermal co-synthesis strategy and was applied for photocatalytic CO₂RR to produce CO and CH₄ ^[114]. Without the use of any sacrificial reagents, the composite with a Ce:Zr molar ratio of 2:8 exhibited the highest CO production rate of 6.01 μmol·g^-1·h^-1 and a selectivity of 54.98%. These values were 3.72 and 17.83 times higher than those of CdIn₂S₄ and NH₂-UiO-66, respectively. This high photocatalytic reduction performance was attributed to the oxygen vacancies generated by doping mixed-valence Ce ions (Ce³⁺/Ce⁴⁺), as well as the enhanced charge separation efficiency resulting from the formation of the heterojunction (Figure 13b).

Cs₃Bi₂Br₉ QDs were incorporated into UiO-66 to form an S-scheme heterojunction^[116], which combined the high porosity and SSA of UiO-66 with the superior power conversion capability of the QDs. It was demonstrated that the composite material Cs₃Bi₂Br₉@UiO-66 exhibited better photocatalytic activity for CO₂RR compared with the composite of large-sized Cs₃Bi₂Br₉ and UiO-66. An S-scheme photocatalyst, NH₂-UiO-66/CuZnS, was also constructed to reduce the band gap of ZnS by in situ growing NH₂-UiO-66 on CuZnS via a microwave hydrothermal method^[117]. This system enabled a thermally assisted photocatalytic CO₂ reduction process. The reaction temperature increased to 54.2 °C due to the photothermal conversion effect of CuZnS, resulting in a CO yield of 22.85 μmol·g^-1·h^-1.

The covalent bonds in heterostructure composite materials can accelerate interfacial electron transfer, shorten the migration path of photoproduced electrons, and enhance the electron utilization rate. Zhao et al.^[115] reported a type of covalently bonded NH₂-UiO-66/RGO composite photocatalyst for CO₂RR (Figure 13c). The presence of covalent bonds in these composites rendered them highly catalytically active, achieving CO yields up to 23.54 μmol·g^-1, which was approximately 13 times that of pure NH₂-UiO-66. Another covalently linked heterostructure, CdSeTe QDs/NH₂-UiO-66, was prepared via the introduction of an acylamino group^[118]. It was shown that the acylamino group functioned not only as a photogenerated charge transfer channel between the two components but also as a stabilizing agent for the QDs. The optimized catalyst achieved a CO generation rate of 228.68 μmol·g^-1, which was 4 and 13 times higher than those of CdSeTe QDs and NH₂-UiO-66, respectively.

The construction of heterojunction is the most effective and straightforward approach to enhance catalytic performance. It can overcome the limitations of single-component materials that suffer from inefficient electron-hole separation and can generate synergistic effects that significantly improve photocatalytic properties. Therefore, future research should focus on developing more efficient and stable heterojunction structures to further improve electron-hole separation efficiency. In addition, the actual transport pathways of electrons and holes at heterojunction interfaces require more systematic investigation.

3.4.3 Other methods

In addition to serving as a co-catalyst and forming heterojunctions, UiO-MOFs can also be combined with other materials to leverage their inherent properties for enhancing photocatalytic activity. This enhancement can be achieved by reducing the agglomeration of UiO-MOF particles, improving the conductivity or light utilization efficiency of composites, constructing strong coordination bonds, or increasing CO₂ adsorption capacity.

A poly(triphenylamine) (PTPA)-decorated NH₂-UiO-66 photocatalyst was prepared through a hydrothermal process^[121], in which NH₂-UiO-66 NPs were highly dispersed on PTPA, which possesses a large surface area (Figure 14). PTPA not only stabilized NH₂-UiO-66 NPs against aggregation but also provided an electron transport channel that facilitated rapid separation of electrons and holes. The resulting composite photocatalyst exhibited enhanced CO₂ adsorption capacity and improved visible light response, leading to better photocatalytic performance for CO₂ reduction to HCOOH. The sample containing 30 wt% PTPA showed a photocatalytic activity 5.5 times higher than that of pure NH₂-UiO-66. Using a microwave-induced approach, well-distributed UiO-66 nanocrystals were grown in situ and assembled onto GR to form an NH₂-UiO-66/GR hybrid^[122]. This composite displayed high activity and selectivity for visible-light-driven photocatalytic CO₂RR toward HCOOH, achieving a HCOOH production rate of 443.75 μmol·g^-1·h^-1, which was 11 times that of pure NH₂-UiO-66. The excellent catalytic performance was attributed to the small particle size of NH₂-UiO-66 crystals and their uniform distribution on the GR surface, the strong CO₂ adsorption capacity, and the robust interaction between the two components formed during the microwave-assisted synthesis process.

Display Full Size

Figure 14. (a) Schematic diagram of the composite structure and proposed photocatalytic CO₂RR mechanism of PTPA/NH₂-UiO-66. Republished with permission from^[121]; (b) Synthesis procedure of TiO₂@UiO-67. Republished with permission from^[123]. CO₂RR: CO₂ reduction reaction.

Based on UiO-67, Saadh et al.^[123] developed a series of composite materials, TiO₂@UiO-67, with varying Ti contents by in situ binding TiO₂ nanosheets onto UiO-67 with linker defects, thereby forming charge-polarized active sites at the TiO₂ and UiO-67 interface. These composites exhibited highly activity and selectivity for visible-light-driven photocatalytic CO₂RR to produce ethane, achieving yields of up to 79.3 μmol·g^-1·h^-1 with 100% selectivity.

4. Conclusions and Prospects

Over the past few years, numerous UiO-based photocatalysts have been evolved for CO₂ reduction. The significant advantages of UiO-MOFs, including large SSA, permanent porosity, abundant active sites, efficient charge separation, and high thermal and chemical stability, provide a unique platform for the development of efficient photocatalysts. As a result, related research has entered a flourishing stage. Due to the limited photocatalytic efficiency of pristine UiO materials, various modification strategies have been employed to improve their performance, mainly including band-gap engineering, defect engineering, introduction of metal species, and combination with other materials. The functional modification of UiO-MOFs and their applications in photocatalytic CO₂RR have been comprehensively reviewed and discussed in this article. Through the modification of UiOs, the following primary objectives can be achieved: (1) increasing specific surface area to enhance CO₂ adsorption capacity and the concentration of active sites, (2) broadening the light absorption range and improving light utilization efficiency, (3) introducing effective active sites to enhance reaction efficiency, and (4) constructing tight interfacial connections between active sites and other components to provide faster pathways for photogenerated charge carrier transfer and separation.

Although considerable advances have been made in the development of UiO-based materials for photocatalytic CO₂RR, their practical applications remain limited. To address this issue, several challenges should be taken into consideration in future research.

(1) Various sacrificial electron donors are widely used in nearly all reported UiO-based photocatalyst systems; however, they have received very limited attention to date. On the one hand, it would be an interesting research direction to investigate the influence of sacrificial reagents and their reaction products on the photocatalytic performance of UiO-based materials. On the other hand, the selection of low-cost, abundant, and sustainable sacrificial agents should be carefully considered. Additionally, coupling with other photocatalytic processes such as oxidation or pollutant degradation to replace traditional sacrificial reagents is expected to enhance the overall economic feasibility.

(2) There is limited research on the photocatalytic mechanism of CO₂RR over UiO-based materials. Gaining more direct evidence on the transfer process of photoproduced charge carriers would represent a significant advancement in understanding the photocatalytic mechanism. Therefore, it is highly desirable to employ in situ characterization and time-resolved detection techniques combined with DFT calculations to obtain more intuitive and accurate results by investigating the electronic and structural evolution of UiO-based photocatalysts, as well as the dynamics of charge carriers.

(3) Developing highly selective catalysts for the production of specific single products has always been a key goal in photocatalytic CO₂RR. However, for most UiO-MOF-based catalysts, CO is usually the main product, often accompanied by by-products such as CH₄. Therefore, there is a strong demand to achieve selective control over the generation of specific single products through sophisticated catalyst design, particularly by fine tuning of the local structure of catalytic active sites and the band structure of the photocatalyst.

(4) Most research in this area is conducted at the lab scale, typically using an Xe lamp as the excitation source, and simple target substances allow UiO-based photocatalysts to perform their catalytic function under relatively mild conditions. However, it is important to note that the photocatalytic performance of these catalysts under actual sunlight, in the presence of other ions, varying pH values, and complex environments, may differ significantly from lab results. Additionally, most UiO-based photocatalysts are used in powder form with catalytic systems, which poses challenges for recycling efficiency and stability in large-scale applications.

Furthermore, for practical applications, UiO-MOFs generally face challenges such as complex synthesis process, the use of large amounts of toxic organic solvents during synthesis, relatively high production cost, and the need to improve stability, recyclability, as well as acid and alkali resistance. To address these issues, it is necessary to develop synthesis methods that are environmentally friendly, energy-efficient, simple, capable of producing high crystallinity materials, and suitable for large-scale production.

Authors contribution

Shi L: Data analysis and interpretation, article conception and design, writing-original draft.

Xin T: Investigation, formal analysis.

Peng C, Wu Z: Formal analysis, investigation.

Liu S: Article conception, supervision.

Yu K, Lou LL: Article conception and design, supervision, writing-review & editing.

Conflicts of interest

There are no conflicts to declare.

Ethical approval

Not applicable.

Consent to participate

Not applicable.

Consent for publication

Not applicable.

Availability of data and material

Not applicable.

Funding

This work was supported by the National Key Research and Development Program of China (Grant No. 2022YFC3901401), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos. 22172081 and U23A20125), the Science and Technology Project of Tianjin (Grant Nos. 21ZXCCSN00010 and 23JCYBJC01820), NCC Fund (Grant NCC2020PY02), and the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities.

Copyright

© The Author(s) 2025.