A review of indoor environmental quality studies using discrete choice experiments: Valuing comfort
-
Thermal comfort, indoor air quality, lighting comfort, and acoustic comfort are often treated as separate domains, despite interacting trade-offs. The discrete choice experiment (DCE) technique helps to account for explicit and implicit factors influencing ...
MoreThermal comfort, indoor air quality, lighting comfort, and acoustic comfort are often treated as separate domains, despite interacting trade-offs. The discrete choice experiment (DCE) technique helps to account for explicit and implicit factors influencing choices, giving a more holistic view of indoor comfort. This paper reviews discrete choice experiment studies that include indoor environmental comfort elements. From 1,418 records found in scientific databases, 21 studies were reviewed. By analysing these studies, DCE’s ability to value indoor comfort was evaluated and methodological deficiencies identified. Given the heterogeneity between studies, this review focused on analysing the p-value and the direction of estimates. Thermal comfort in these studies shows positive and statistically significant coefficients, indoor air quality is generally positive but statistically heterogeneous. Evidence for positively valued lighting and acoustic comfort is frequently statistically non-significant. Methodological challenges identified affecting indoor environmental quality (IEQ) valuation in DCEs include proxy dilution, insufficient attribute clarity, embedded cost signals, and demographic heterogeneity. Proxy-based operationalisations may confound comfort valuation with convenience, cost, or multi-domain interaction effects. Additionally, occupant control and agency emerge as meta-attributes that generate utility beyond environmental improvement. Survey-based DCE can reliably elicit thermal comfort preferences from occupants; experiential approaches such as virtual reality-based DCE may allow occupants to better value acoustic and lighting comfort. Overall findings suggest indoor comfort should be modelled as a multi-attribute bundle instead of separate domains. This review shows that DCE is a useful tool for analysing indoor comfort as a bundle of attributes with strong interaction effects.
Less -
Ahmad Syahid, ... Hom Bahadur Rijal
-
DOI: https://doi.org/10.70401/jbde.2026.0037 - April 14, 2026

